If you think you’ve tried every margarita under the sun—think again. As a chef who loves pushing flavor boundaries, I couldn’t resist turning a childhood favorite into a grown-up cocktail with a twist. Enter the PB&J Margarita: a bold, playful blend of creamy peanut butter, sweet jelly, and that classic citrusy kick of lime.
This isn’t just a drink—it’s a conversation starter. The unexpected combo creates a rich, tangy-sweet balance that surprises in the best way. Whether you’re entertaining guests or just treating yourself, this cocktail is guaranteed to bring a smile (and maybe a little nostalgia) to every sip.
🍸 What Is a PB&J Margarita?
The PB&J Margarita is not your typical cocktail. It takes the comforting flavors of a peanut butter and jelly sandwich and transforms them into a fun, flavorful margarita with a grown-up twist. Think of it as a drink that brings out your inner child—while still packing the punch of a proper cocktail. The rich nuttiness of peanut butter blends with fruity jelly and zesty lime juice, all balanced by the bold kick of tequila. It’s creative, playful, and guaranteed to surprise your taste buds.
💛 Why You’ll Love the PB&J Margarita
This drink isn’t just different—it’s deliciously different. Here’s why you’re going to fall in love with it:
- Unexpected Flavor Magic – The combo may sound strange at first, but it works beautifully. The creamy peanut butter softens the tartness of the lime, and the jelly adds a sweet, fruity finish. It’s the perfect balance of sweet, sour, salty, and smooth.
- It’s a Conversation Starter – Whether you’re hosting friends or just treating yourself, this cocktail will have everyone asking, “Wait…what’s in this?!” And after one sip, they’ll be hooked.
- Nostalgic Meets Sophisticated – It brings together childhood memories with adult flavors. It’s playful but elegant—a cocktail that’s as charming as it is tasty.
- Perfect for Parties – Fun drinks make fun gatherings! This recipe is great for themed parties, brunches, or any night you want to shake things up with something unique.
👅 What Does a PB&J Margarita Taste Like?
One sip, and you’ll be surprised—in the best way. It starts with a bright citrus tang from the lime, followed by the smooth richness of peanut butter. Then the sweet jelly kicks in, adding fruity depth that ties everything together. The tequila gives it warmth and complexity, making each sip layered and exciting. The result? A cocktail that’s creamy, slightly tart, subtly sweet, and completely unlike anything you’ve tried before.
It may sound bold, but trust me—it’s weirdly wonderful.
Print
PB&J Margarita Recipe
- Total Time: 4 minutes
- Yield: Servings: 1
Description
A playful twist on a childhood favorite, the PB&J Margarita brings the classic peanut butter and jelly flavors into a bold and boozy cocktail. Smooth tequila meets rich peanut butter whiskey for a nutty depth,
Ingredients
2 oz tequila
1 oz peanut butter whiskey
1 oz lime juice
1 oz grape jelly or grape juice
0.5 oz simple syrup
Peanut butter and salt for rimming the glass
Lime wedge for garnish
Instructions
Prepare the Glass:
Mix the Drink:
Strain and Serve:
Garnish:
Enjoy:
Notes
For a smoother blend, dissolve the grape jelly in the lime juice before shaking.
Use a high-quality peanut butter whiskey like Skrewball for the best nutty flavor.
For an extra PB&J feel, drizzle a little grape jelly inside the glass before pouring the drink.
If you want a creamier version, add a splash of oat milk or half & half.
Try a cinnamon sugar rim instead of salt for a sweeter twist!
- Prep Time: 4minutes
- Category: Drinks
- Cuisine: Mexican
Keywords: Margarita, Tequila
🥄 Tasting Notes – What to Expect in Every Sip
The PB&J Margarita isn’t just a fun novelty—it’s a flavor journey you won’t forget. It starts with the smooth, rich taste of peanut butter whiskey, which gives the drink a creamy, nutty base. Then comes the burst of fruity sweetness from grape jelly or grape juice, adding that familiar PB&J vibe you loved as a kid. But don’t worry—this cocktail still stays true to its margarita roots. Fresh lime juice adds brightness and a tangy zip, while tequila brings in warmth and balance. The real star? The peanut butter–salt rim, which ties everything together with a sweet-and-salty finish that enhances each flavor note. The final result is bold, creamy, tangy, a little sweet, and just quirky enough to impress any adventurous sipper.
🍹 Equipment & Glassware – What You’ll Need
Making a PB&J Margarita is simple when you have the right tools. Start with a cocktail shaker to mix all the ingredients thoroughly and chill the drink. Use a strainer to keep your pour smooth and free of jelly bits or ice chunks. For serving, a rocks glass gives it a casual feel, while a margarita glass adds flair—either works perfectly. You’ll also want a jigger to measure out the ingredients precisely (cocktails are all about balance!), and don’t forget a small plate for preparing that fun and flavorful peanut butter–salt rim. Just spread a little peanut butter on the rim, dip it in salt, and you’ve got a rim that’s tasty and totally unexpected.
🕒 When to Serve the PB&J Margarita
This cocktail is more than just a drink—it’s an experience. The PB&J Margarita is perfect for moments when you want to surprise and delight. Serve it as a dessert cocktail after dinner when your guests are expecting something sweet and unique. It’s also a hit at creative happy hours, themed parties, or any casual get-together where people are open to trying something playful. This drink is a must for nostalgia lovers, especially those who grew up with peanut butter and jelly sandwiches and now enjoy a good cocktail. And if you’re a fan of peanut butter whiskey, this recipe is practically made for you. It’s unexpected, conversation-worthy, and always gets a reaction—usually smiles and requests for another round!
🥃 Which Liquor Brands to Use for the Best PB&J Margarita
To make this cocktail shine, quality ingredients are key. For tequila, go with a smooth blanco variety that won’t overpower the other flavors. Top choices include Casamigos Blanco, Espolòn Blanco, or Don Julio Blanco—all are known for their clean, crisp profiles that pair beautifully with citrus and sweet notes.
For the peanut butter component, Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey is the gold standard. It’s creamy, sweet, and packed with that rich peanut flavor that makes this drink so special.
As for the jelly part, you have two great options: organic grape juice (for a smoother, more drinkable feel) or high-quality grape jelly (for a thicker, more indulgent texture). Either way, aim for something with real fruit and no artificial flavors to keep the cocktail tasting fresh and authentic.
Similar Cocktails
If you’re a fan of the PB&J Margarita’s bold, playful flavors, there’s a whole world of creative cocktails waiting for you. These drinks share that same spirit of nostalgia, fruit-forward flavor, or unexpected twists that make sipping an experience. Here are a few delicious options to explore:
🍋 Amalfi Martini with Limoncello – This elegant cocktail blends the bright citrusy notes of Limoncello with vodka or gin for a zesty, Italian-inspired martini that’s smooth and slightly sweet.
🍓 Strawberry Lemonade Sangria – A refreshing and fruity sangria that combines sweet strawberries with tart lemonade and a splash of wine or vodka. It’s perfect for sunny afternoons and picnic vibes.
❓ PB&J Margarita – Frequently Asked Questions
1. Can I use regular tequila instead of blanco?
Yes! Blanco tequila is preferred for its clean flavor, but reposado can add a warmer, oaky note if you enjoy deeper flavor profiles.
2. What type of peanut butter works best?
Smooth peanut butter or peanut butter whiskey (like Skrewball) is best for easy mixing. Avoid chunky styles—they won’t blend well in the shaker.
3. Do I have to use grape jelly?
Not at all! Grape jelly gives it that classic PB&J feel, but you can experiment with strawberry, raspberry, or even blackberry jelly for a twist.
4. Can I make a non-alcoholic version?
Yes! Swap tequila and peanut butter whiskey with non-alcoholic spirits or simply use peanut butter, lime juice, grape juice, and a splash of soda water.
5. How do I keep the jelly from clumping?
Mix the jelly with lime juice first to loosen it up, or slightly warm it before shaking. You can also use juice instead for a smoother drink.
6. What’s the best way to rim the glass?
Spread a thin layer of peanut butter on the rim and dip it into a mix of coarse salt or sugar (or both!). It’s delicious and adds extra texture.
7. Can I batch this cocktail for a party?
Absolutely! Multiply the ingredients and mix them in a pitcher (without ice). When ready to serve, shake individual portions with ice and pour.
8. Is this cocktail too sweet?
Nope! The lime juice and tequila help balance the sweetness from the jelly and peanut butter, keeping it refreshing and not overly sugary.
9. Can I garnish it?
Yes! A mini PB&J sandwich triangle, a lime wedge, or even a drizzle of jelly inside the glass adds a fun and visual touch.
10. How long can I store leftovers?
It’s best enjoyed fresh, but you can store pre-mixed ingredients (without ice) in the fridge for up to 24 hours. Shake before serving.
🎉 Conclusion: A Childhood Classic, All Grown Up
The PB&J Margarita is more than just a fun cocktail—it’s a delightful mix of nostalgia and creativity in a glass. Whether you’re a fan of peanut butter whiskey, always loved the classic sandwich, or just enjoy trying bold new drinks, this recipe brings joy, surprise, and great flavor. It’s sweet, tangy, creamy, and just a little quirky—in the best way possible.
So go ahead, shake one up, rim that glass with peanut butter, and toast to childhood favorites with an adult twist. Ready to give it a try tonight?